Based on a true story told in a book with the same name, Lost on a Mountain in Maine tells the tale of Donn (played by Luke David Blumm), a boy who gets into a fight with his father during a hike. Upset, he decides to climb a mountain without the right gear, ignoring the difficult weather conditions. Donn spends nine days lost in the Maine wilderness and walks about 80 miles before he is rescued.
At one point in Lost on a Mountain in Maine, someone mentions that the story of Donn Fendler “was really a miracle.” This statement suggests that the story is full of hope and wonder.
However, the movie does not show this miracle well. The film runs for 98 minutes, but throughout that time, it feels like it misses the weight of the story. What should be a gripping tale turns out to feel plain and uninteresting.
What Is Lost on a Mountain in Maine About?
Donn’s real-life experience is impressive and remarkable. His story is the kind of material that Hollywood often turns into inspiring movies. Yet, the issue with Lost on a Mountain in Maine is that the director, Andrew Boodhoo Kightlinger, and screenwriter Luke Paradise do not make enough effort to make the story exciting beyond its basic elements. During the movie, it feels more like the filmmakers are ticking off a checklist than truly telling a powerful story.
The movie touches on various themes, such as family drama and the fight between Donn and his father. These themes are indeed present, but they do not develop into a deeper narrative. Instead of showing us the real emotional struggles of the characters, the film settles for a surface-level treatment of important issues.
One major missed opportunity is the emotional journey of Donn’s parents, especially his mother, Ruth (played by Caitlin FitzGerald). Throughout the movie, she appears calm and collected, lacking a strong emotional reaction to her son’s disappearance.
This portrayal makes it hard for viewers to feel the true weight of the situation. It’s difficult to tell if she has lost her son or simply misplaced a sweater. The film does not show her feelings of desperation, which could have added a significant layer to the story.
The Parents’ Experience
Ruth’s character fails to show the emotional depth one would expect from a mother whose child is missing. Even if one thinks she is too numb to display real emotions, the film does not highlight this aspect. The surroundings and situations do not reflect a mother’s growing worry as she begins to lose hope.
Donn’s father, Donald (played by Paul Sparks), has a bit more room to show his emotions. He sometimes acts out, which makes it easy to see that he regrets how he treats Donn. However, like Ruth, Donald does not show every option to find his son. Instead, they seem to accept that Donn is lost and hope for his safe return without showing much action or determination.
This lack of urgency and despair in the parents’ behavior makes it hard for viewers to connect with their plight. They accept their son’s disappearance without showing how frantic and hopeless the search would truly be.
Misguided Storytelling Choices
The film seems to realize it is not effectively capturing the gravity of Donn’s story, so it makes the odd decision to include real-life accounts from people who experienced the events of 1939. These talking heads share their shock and admiration for Donn’s story. However, the film fails to match their wonder and excitement.
One significant disappointment is how the film treats the real Donn. He is not introduced until the end of the movie, where he speaks for only ten seconds. This moment feels too brief, especially when viewers would likely be eager to hear from the person who lived through the ordeal.
As the story progresses, viewers follow Donn during the nine days he is lost. Unfortunately, the film fails to show his desperation. Donn does not appear to struggle in a meaningful way, facing few challenges except for walking until someone finds him. Given how many stories exist about survival, such as 127 Hours, Cast Away, and Into the Wild, this film struggles to present anything unique or engaging.
A Deeper Character Scheme Needed
The movie does not require an extreme or dramatic situation to be compelling. It simply needs to goes deeper into Donn’s thoughts and feelings during his ordeal. Providing insight into his mind could create a more interesting narrative.
When the movie allows Donn to become a bit delirious, it gives viewers a view into his imagination and thoughts. These moments shine compared to the rest of the film, showing that the story could have had more depth and creativity.
The Siblings’ Perspectives
One of the strengths of Lost on a Mountain in Maine is how it sets up Donn’s relationships with his siblings. This connection pulls viewers into the story early on. However, as the film progresses, the siblings become largely forgotten. We do not hear their perspectives, nor do we see how they react when the adults are not present.
The absence of the siblings in the story is a significant flaw. They could provide important insights into the family dynamic and how the entire family feels during this crisis. The movie misses the chance to show how the siblings cope with their brother’s disappearance, which would have added another layer of emotional complexity to the film.
A Series of Missed Opportunities
Lost on a Mountain in Maine attempts to convince the audience that it tells a remarkable story, but it does not do enough work to back that up. Each element of the story is shown only at a surface level. The potential stakes of the story, which could be extremely high, feel barely present.
The film presents many missed opportunities to create a compelling narrative. The characters could have been developed further to give viewers a better understanding of their feelings and motivations. Instead, the film settles for a shallow retelling of events that leaves viewers wanting more.
Emotional Connection to the Story
At its core, Lost on a Mountain in Maine has the potential to be a powerful tale about survival and the human spirit. However, it misses the chance to connect with the audience on an emotional level. The film does not go deep enough into the feelings of fear, hope, and despair that surround Donn’s experience.
For a story about a boy lost in the wilderness, there is surprisingly little focus on the actual survival aspect. The film could have included more of Donn’s challenges, such as finding food, staying warm, and coping with fear and loneliness. These are vital parts of any survival story, and their absence is felt throughout the film.
The Setting and Cinematography
While the film does a decent job of portraying the beautiful but treacherous Maine wilderness, it fails to fully utilize this setting to enhance the story. The majestic mountains and dense forests could serve as a powerful backdrop for Donn’s journey. However, the cinematography does not capture the danger and beauty of the wilderness in a way that adds tension or excitement to the story.
The lack of visual storytelling in Lost on a Mountain in Maine leaves viewers feeling disconnected from the journey. Instead of feeling the weight of Donn’s struggle against nature, audiences are left with a sense of detachment. A stronger visual narrative could have helped convey the story’s emotional stakes.
Comparing with Other Survival Films
When comparing Lost on a Mountain in Maine to other survival films, it becomes clear how much it lacks. Movies like 127 Hours and Into the Wild showcase characters who are pushed to their limits.
They capture the intense feelings of fear, desperation, and even moments of hope. These films allow audiences to feel the weight of survival in a way that Lost on a Mountain in Maine does not.
The failure to create a similar emotional connection is disappointing. Audiences want to root for the protagonist and experience their struggles. Instead, Lost on a Mountain in Maine offers a flat portrayal that does not engage viewers in the same way.
Audience Expectations
Given the true story behind Lost on a Mountain in Maine, audiences may come to the film expecting an inspiring tale of survival. However, they might leave feeling unsatisfied. The film does not fulfill the promise of a gripping adventure. Instead, it leaves many questions unanswered and many emotions unexplored.
Viewers want to connect with the characters and feel their emotions. However, the film’s surface-level approach makes it difficult to truly engage with the story. As a result, it becomes a missed opportunity to create something meaningful and memorable.
Conclusion
Lost on a Mountain in Maine premieres in theaters on November 1. Despite its compelling source material, the film fails to deliver a powerful story. The lack of emotional depth, character scheme, and engaging visuals makes it hard for viewers to connect with the narrative.
Donn Fendler’s journey is remarkable, and his survival story has the potential to inspire. Unfortunately, this film does not do justice to that potential. It is a series of missed opportunities that could have created a more engaging and emotional experience for the audience.
In the end, Lost on a Mountain in Maine serves as a reminder of what could have been. It tells a story of survival but does so in a way that feels uninspired and flat. Audiences may leave feeling that they did not fully experience the miracle of Donn’s story, making it a film that falls short of its promise.